KYIV/PARIS: When the primary armoured automobiles of Russia‘s invading military reached the guts of Chornobyl nuclear plant on the afternoon of February 24, they encountered a Ukrainian unit charged with defending the infamous facility.
In lower than two hours, and with out a struggle, the 169 members of the Ukrainian Nationwide Guard laid down their weapons. Russia had taken Chornobyl, a repository for tonnes of nuclear materials and a key staging publish on the strategy to Kyiv.
The autumn of Chornobyl, web site of the world’s worst nuclear catastrophe, stands out as an anomaly within the five-month outdated conflict: a profitable blitzkrieg operation in a battle marked elsewhere by a brutal and halting advance by Russian troops and grinding resistance by Ukraine.
Now a Reuters investigation has discovered that Russia’s success at Chornobyl was no accident, however a part of a long-standing Kremlin operation to infiltrate the Ukrainian state with secret brokers.
5 individuals with information of the Kremlin’s preparations stated conflict planners round President Vladimir Putin believed that, aided by these brokers, Russia would require solely a small navy power and some days to power Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy’s administration to give up, flee or capitulate.
By interviews with dozens of officers in Russia and Ukraine and a assessment of Ukrainian courtroom paperwork and statements to investigators, associated to a probe into the conduct of people that labored at Chornobyl, Reuters has established that this infiltration reached far deeper than has been publicly acknowledged. The officers interviewed embody individuals inside Russia who had been briefed on Moscow’s invasion planning and Ukrainian investigators tasked with monitoring down spies.
“Aside from the exterior enemy, we sadly have an inside enemy, and this enemy is not any much less harmful,” the secretary of Ukraine’s Nationwide Safety and Defence Council, Oleksiy Danilov, stated in an interview.
On the time of the invasion, Danilov stated, Russia had brokers within the Ukrainian defence, safety and regulation enforcement sectors. He declined to provide names however stated such traitors wanted to be “neutralised” in any respect prices.
Ukraine’s State Bureau of Investigation is conducting a probe into whether or not the Nationwide Guard acted unlawfully by surrendering its weapons to an enemy, an area official instructed Reuters. The State Bureau of Investigation did not remark. The Nationwide Guard defended the actions of its unit on the plant, pointing to the dangers of battle at a nuclear web site.
Courtroom paperwork and testimony, reported right here for the primary time, reveal the function performed by Chornobyl’s head of safety, Valentin Viter, who’s in detention and is being investigated for absenting himself from his publish. An extract from the state register of pre-trial investigations, seen by Reuters, exhibits Viter can be suspected of treason, an allegation his lawyer says is unfounded. In a press release to investigators, Viter stated that on the day of the invasion he spoke by telephone with the Nationwide Guard unit commander. Viter suggested the commander to not endanger his unit, telling him: “Spare your individuals.”
One supply with direct information of the Kremlin’s invasion plans instructed Reuters that Russian brokers had been deployed to Chornobyl final 12 months to bribe officers and put together the bottom for a cold takeover. Reuters could not independently confirm the main points of this assertion. Nevertheless, Ukraine’s State Bureau of Investigation has stated it’s investigating a former high intelligence official, Andriy Naumov, on suspicion of treason for passing Chornobyl safety secrets and techniques to a international state. A lawyer for Naumov declined to remark.
At a nationwide degree, sources with information of the Kremlin’s plans stated Moscow was relying on activating sleeper brokers contained in the Ukrainian safety equipment. The sources confirmed Western intelligence reviews that the Kremlin was lining up Oleg Tsaryov, a hotelier, to guide a puppet authorities in Kyiv. And a former Ukrainian prosecutor basic disclosed to Reuters in June that Ukrainian politician Viktor Medvedchuk, a buddy of Putin, had an encrypted telephone issued by Russia so he may talk with the Kremlin.
Tsaryov stated the Reuters account of how Moscow’s operation total unfolded “has little or no to do with actuality.” He didn’t handle his relationship with the Kremlin. A lawyer for Medvedchuk declined to remark. Medvedchuk is in a Ukrainian jail awaiting trial on treason costs that pre-date the Russian invasion.
Although Russia captured Chornobyl, its plan to take energy in Kyiv failed. In lots of instances, the sleeper brokers Moscow had put in didn’t do their job, in response to a number of sources in Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine Safety Council Secretary Danilov stated the brokers and their handlers believed Ukraine was weak, which was “a complete false impression.”
Folks the Kremlin counted on as its proxies in Ukraine overstated their affect within the years main as much as the invasion, stated 4 of the sources with information of the Kremlin’s preparations. The Kremlin relied in its planning on “clowns – they know slightly bit, however they all the time say what the management needs to listen to as a result of in any other case they will not receives a commission,” stated one of many 4, an individual near the Moscow-backed separatist management in japanese Ukraine.
Putin now finds himself in a protracted, full-scale conflict, preventing for each inch of territory at enormous value.
However the Russian intelligence infiltration did achieve a technique: It has sown distrust inside Ukraine and laid naked the shortcomings of Ukraine’s close to 30,000-strong Safety Service of Ukraine, or SBU, which shares an advanced historical past with Russia, and is now tasked with looking down traitors and collaborators.
This inside Ukrainian turmoil burst into partial view on July 17. In a video handle to the nation, President Zelenskiy suspended SBU head Ivan Bakanov, whom he has recognized for years, citing the massive variety of SBU employees suspected of treason. Ukrainian regulation enforcement sources instructed Reuters that some SBU employees recounted in dialog with them that they had been unable to succeed in Bakanov for a number of days after Russia invaded, including to a way of chaos in Kyiv. Bakanov did not reply to Reuters’ requests for remark.
Zelenskiy additionally stated 651 instances of alleged treason and collaboration have been opened in opposition to people concerned in regulation enforcement and within the prosecutor’s workplace. Greater than 60 officers from the SBU and the prosecutor basic’s workplace are working in opposition to Ukraine in Russian-occupied zones, Zelenskiy added.
Requested to touch upon Reuters’ findings, the Ukrainian presidential administration, the SBU and the prosecutor basic’s workplace didn’t reply. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov stated: “All these questions haven’t any relation in any way to us, subsequently there may be nothing for us to touch upon right here.” The Russian intelligence company, the FSB, and the defence ministry didn’t reply to Reuters’ questions.
KGB ties
Moscow’s spy equipment has been intertwined with Chornobyl for many years. After the 1986 catastrophe, when a reactor blew up scattering radioactive clouds throughout Europe, the Soviet KGB stepped in. Greater than 1,000 KGB employees took half within the clean-up, in response to a declassified inside memo to a Ukrainian authorities minister, dated 1991. Then-KGB boss Viktor Chebrikov ordered his officers to recruit brokers among the many plant’s employees and instructed {that a} KGB officer ought to maintain the publish of deputy boss of the plant in command of safety, in response to one other memo – an inside KGB communication from 1986.
Even after Ukraine turned unbiased in 1991, Moscow’s spy chiefs remained highly effective there. The primary head of Ukraine’s home intelligence service was Nikolai Golushko, who began his profession in Soviet Russia. Earlier than his appointment he led the Ukraine arm of the Soviet KGB. Golushko saved many of the Soviet-era officers of their jobs, he wrote in a 2012 memoir.
After 4 months as Ukraine’s spy chief, Golushko moved again to Moscow to rejoin KGB headquarters, and in 1993 turned head of Russia’s newly created Federal Counter-Intelligence Service, precursor to at this time’s FSB.
In Moscow, Golushko obtained a go to from the deputy head of Ukraine’s State Safety Service, Golushko wrote within the memoir. He recalled how Oleg Pugach, the Ukrainian official, requested for Golushko’s assist discovering material to make the uniforms for Ukraine’s intelligence officers. Golushko additionally wrote that Kyiv, wanting its personal assets and experience, signed offers underneath which the SBU agreed to share intelligence info with Moscow. In change, Moscow offered provides, know-how and knowledgeable assist with investigations. Reuters approached Golushko for remark. A colleague from an intelligence veterans’ group instructed Reuters Golushko, now 85, was in unwell well being and couldn’t reply questions. Reuters was unable to succeed in Pugach and could not independently verify Golushko’s account.
Intelligence officers working at Chornobyl formally turned a part of Ukraine’s safety equipment in 1991, however they continued to take orders from Moscow, stated the individual with direct information of the invasion plan. “In impact, these had been FSB workers,” stated the individual. The SBU didn’t reply to questions on Chornobyl or historic ties to Russian intelligence.
The Chornobyl nuclear plant is an unlimited facility. A large metal construction encases Reactor No. 4, floor zero of the 1986 catastrophe. The plant lies simply 10 kilometres on the closest level from the border with Belarus, in a dense and extremely irradiated forest. Russia’s conflict planners thought of management of Chornobyl to be strategically essential as a result of it sat on the shortest route for his or her advance on Kyiv, in response to Western navy analysts.
The supply with direct information of the invasion plan stated that in November 2021 Russia began sending undercover intelligence brokers to Ukraine, tasked with establishing contacts with officers accountable for securing the Chornobyl energy plant. The brokers’ purpose was to make sure there could be no armed resistance as soon as Russian troops rolled in. The supply stated Chornobyl additionally served as a drop-off level for paperwork from SBU headquarters. In return for cost, Ukrainian officers handed Russian spies details about Ukraine’s navy readiness.
Reuters couldn’t independently confirm particulars of the supply’s account, and neither Ukraine’s State Bureau of Investigation nor the SBU responded to the information company’s questions. However a assessment of Ukrainian testimony and courtroom paperwork and an interview with an area official present that Kyiv is conducting no less than three investigations into the conduct of people that labored at Chornobyl. The investigations have recognized no less than two individuals suspected of offering info to Russian brokers or in any other case serving to them seize the plant, in response to these paperwork.
One of many males suspected by Ukrainian prosecutors and investigators of serving to Russian forces is Valentin Viter, a 47-year-old colonel within the SBU. On the time of the Russian invasion, Viter was the deputy general-director of the plant accountable for its bodily safety.
In Might final 12 months, Viter oversaw a routine coaching train that was meant to simulate an assault by armed saboteurs. Armed members of the Nationwide Guard unit that protects Chornobyl took half, and rehearsed repelling the attackers by power. Viter stated the train was a hit, in response to a video interview posted shortly afterwards on the plant’s web site. He additionally stated he hoped Chornobyl’s safety staff would “not want to use the information and expertise we acquired in a real-life state of affairs.”
Viter was seconded from the SBU to work at Chornobyl as safety chief in mid-2019, in response to a press release he gave to investigators. In an extra assertion, he stated that on February 18 this 12 months – six days earlier than the Russian invasion – he went on sick go away with a respiratory downside.
By then, Russia was bolstering its troops in Belarus in preparation for an invasion, U.S. officers stated on the time. Satellite tv for pc pictures shot by U.S. satellite tv for pc imagery firm Maxar on February 15 confirmed a navy pontoon bridge underneath development throughout the Pripyat River in Belarus, north of the ability plant. Ukraine’s police, and the SBU, had been on heightened alert in response to the Russian risk, and the nationwide police chief stated in a press release on the time that safety was bolstered on the Chornobyl plant.
On the morning of the Russian invasion, February 24, Viter stated, in a press release to investigators, that he was at his dwelling in Kyiv. He telephoned the pinnacle of the Chornobyl Nationwide Guard unit, who was at his publish. By then, individuals on the plant knew a column of Russian armoured automobiles was heading their approach.
Viter, in response to his testimony to Ukrainian investigators, instructed the commander, in Russian: “Spare your individuals.” Viter had no official authority over the Nationwide Guard, and Reuters couldn’t decide whether or not the commander was heeding Viter’s phrases when the unit surrendered after discussions with the Russian invaders. A Nationwide Guard assertion recognized the unit commander as Yuriy Pindak.
When the Russian troopers lastly retreated from Chornobyl after a 36-day occupation, they took Pindak and most of his unit away as captives. Ukraine says the guards are being held in Russia or Belarus. Russian officers didn’t touch upon the unit’s whereabouts.
Ukraine’s State Bureau of Investigation is conducting a probe into whether or not the Nationwide Guard broke the regulation by laying down arms, stated Yuriy Fomichev, mayor of the city of Slavutych the place many of the Chornobyl staff dwell. Fomichev stated he was not conscious of anybody having been charged. The State Bureau of Investigation did not reply to Reuters’ questions concerning the matter.
The Nationwide Guard declined to touch upon the actions of particular person commanders and members of the unit tasked with defending Chornobyl. “Combating on the territory of nuclear amenities is prohibited by the Geneva Conference,” it stated, including that this was “one of many causes” why there was no heavy preventing on the web site. It referred questions on any investigation to the Bureau.
Article 56 of a further protocol to the Geneva Conventions states that nuclear energy crops and different harmful installations shouldn’t be attacked.
Viter was arrested in western Ukraine and is now in pre-trial detention there on suspicion of absenting himself from his publish. An extract from the courtroom’s register, seen by Reuters, exhibits that regulation enforcement brokers have initiated a second investigation into Viter for suspected treason by “intentionally helping the navy items of the aggressor nation, the Russian Federation, in finishing up subversive actions in opposition to Ukraine.” They’ve but to uncover proof tying him to Russian particular companies.
Viter has stated in courtroom statements that he fled Kyiv for the protection of his household two days after Chornobyl was seized however tried to remain in touch with colleagues on the plant.
His lawyer, Oleksandr Kovalenko, stated Viter had a official motive for being off work and was unaware that he ought to keep at Chornobyl. The lawyer stated any treason allegation was unfounded and Viter had not been served with a letter of suspicion, a step which often precedes costs. In accordance with the lawyer, Viter stated “Spare your individuals” to remind the Nationwide Guard commander that many individuals trusted him. Viter didn’t focus on give up, Kovalenko stated. He added that investigators had not requested Viter about any change of paperwork at Chornobyl.
Money and emeralds
The extent to which Russia infiltrated Chornobyl has targeted Ukrainian authorities’ consideration on the SBU, the company Viter labored for, sources stated. Particularly, navy prosecutors on Viter’s case are concerned with his connection to a former Ukrainian official known as Andriy Naumov, in response to sources with information of the investigation and a transcript of Viter’s questioning seen by Reuters.
Beforehand an official within the Ukrainian prosecutor’s workplace, by 2018 Naumov had been appointed head of COTIZ, a state enterprise accountable for estate-management of the radioactive exclusion zone round Chornobyl. A serious a part of COTIZ’s function was to advertise “excessive tourism” within the exclusion zone, however the enterprise additionally had a task in holding the location safe, in response to its web site.
After his stint at Chornobyl, Naumov was made the pinnacle of the SBU’s division of inside safety, a division that investigates different officers suspected of prison exercise. Final 12 months, the company stated it thwarted an assassination try on Naumov by different SBU officers. Naumov was later fired as division chief, in response to Ukrainian media outlet Ukrainska Pravda and a regulation enforcement supply.
Naumov vanished shortly earlier than the invasion, an individual in regulation enforcement stated. He ultimately turned up in Serbia in June. A Serbian police assertion issued on June 8 stated police and anti-corruption brokers had arrested a Ukrainian citizen recognized by the initials “A.N.” on the border with North Macedonia. He had been making an attempt to cross into North Macedonia from Serbia. A search of the BMW wherein he was a passenger uncovered $124,924 and 607,990 euros in money, plus two emeralds, the assertion stated. It stated the person and the unnamed driver of the BMW, who was additionally detained, had been suspected of desiring to launder the money and emeralds, which police consider originated from prison actions. Volodymyr Tolkach, Ukraine’s ambassador to Serbia, publicly confirmed the arrested man was Naumov.
The State Bureau of Investigation confirmed an area media report that it’s conducting a pre-trial investigation into Naumov for state treason. It stated it was wanting into whether or not Naumov collected info on the safety set-up at Chornobyl whereas working on the plant and later on the SBU and handed it to a international state. The assertion didn’t say what grounds it had for suspecting he handed on secrets and techniques or if it had particular proof linking him to Russia.
On March 31, President Zelenskiy issued a decree stripping Naumov of his brigadier-general rank. The identical day, the Ukrainian president introduced in an emotional handle that Naumov and one other SBU basic had been “traitors” who violated their oath of allegiance to Ukraine. Zelenskiy didn’t make reference to Chornobyl.
Naumov stays in detention in Serbia and couldn’t be reached for remark. His lawyer in Serbia, Viktor Gostiljac, declined to remark. The SBU didn’t reply to questions on Naumov.
Decapitation
For Russia’s conflict planners, seizing Chornobyl was only a stepping stone to the primary goal: taking management of the Ukrainian nationwide authorities in Kyiv. There, too, the Kremlin anticipated that undercover brokers in positions of energy would play a vital half, in response to 4 sources with information of the plan.
Yuriy Lutsenko, who served as Ukraine’s prosecutor basic from 2016 till 2019, revealed to Reuters that on the time he left the function “lots of” of Defence Ministry workers had been underneath surveillance, authorised by his workplace, as a result of they had been suspected of ties to the Russian state. Lutsenko stated he believed there have been related numbers of suspected spies in different ministries.
Russia’s conflict planners had been additionally relying on different allies to assist in the takeover, 5 sources stated.
Some of the seen loyalists was Viktor Medvedchuk, a frontrunner of Ukraine’s Opposition Platform – For Life social gathering. Putin is god-father to one among Medvedchuk’s kids. Since 2014, Medvedchuk has been a vocal opponent of the favored protests that known as for nearer ties to the European Union.
Medvedchuk was charged with state treason on Might 11, 2021. Investigators from the SBU alleged on the time that Medvedchuk handed secret particulars about Ukrainian navy items to Russian officers, and supposed to recruit Ukrainian brokers and covertly affect Ukrainian politics. The day earlier than the invasion, he left his dwelling in Kyiv and was planning on leaving the nation, in violation of the phrases of his bail, in response to the SBU.
Medvedchuk was detained on April 12, Zelenskiy introduced that day. Zelenskiy instantly posted footage of him handcuffed, in Ukrainian navy fatigues and looking out bedraggled. Medvedchuk has since been in detention.
Medvedchuk has denied the treason costs, saying they had been falsified and a part of a political plot in opposition to him. Kremlin spokesman Peskov instructed reporters on April 13 Medvedchuk had no back-channel communication with the Russian management.
Lutsenko, the previous Ukraine prosecutor basic, instructed Reuters that earlier than the Russian invasion, Medvedchuk used an encrypted phone that was issued to him by the Kremlin, gear reserved just for essentially the most senior Russian officers and pro-Russian separatist leaders. Lutsenko stated Ukrainian investigators had managed to hack the encrypted telephone system, with out disclosing what they discovered.
Medvedchuk’s lawyer, Tetyana Zhukovska, declined to remark till a courtroom has handed down a choice within the case. The Ukrainian prosecutor’s workplace didn’t remark.
One other key determine, in response to three sources aware of the Russian plans, was Oleg Tsaryov, a square-jawed 52-year-old former member of Ukraine’s parliament. He was picked by Kremlin invasion planners to guide the brand new interim authorities they deliberate to put in, these sources stated. Their feedback are the primary affirmation from inside Russia of U.S. intelligence assessments, reported by the Monetary Instances earlier this 12 months, that Moscow was contemplating placing Tsaryov in a management function in a puppet authorities in Kyiv.
Tsaryov has been underneath Ukrainian and U.S. sanctions since 2014, when, after a bid to win election as Ukrainian president collapsed, he headed up a physique known as “Novorossiya,” or New Russia. The group pushed the thought of turning southeastern Ukraine right into a separate pro-Russian statelet. By the beginning of this 12 months, he was in Russian-annexed Crimea, the place he owns two lodges.
Within the early hours of February 24, in the beginning of the invasion, Tsaryov instructed his greater than 200,000 Telegram followers he had crossed into Kyiv-controlled territory. “I am in Ukraine. Kyiv can be free from fascists.”
However Zelenskiy didn’t capitulate. Any expectations in Moscow that he would flee Kyiv or negotiate a deal that will cede to Russia’s calls for quickly evaporated. Within the weeks that adopted, Ukrainian forces halted Russian troops’ advance on Kyiv.
Tsaryov by no means made it to the capital. On June 10, he posted an commercial to his Telegram followers for his seaside resort in Crimea, the place a one-night keep prices 1,500 roubles ($28) per individual per evening. Tsaryov is now spending his time in Crimea with visits to Moscow, in response to his social media posts.
Paranoia and distrust
Russia’s marketing campaign of infiltration did, nevertheless, stir suspicion and distrust at some ranges of the Ukrainian state, which hampered its capacity to manipulate, particularly within the first few days after the invasion.
One stark incident that fuelled the tensions in Kyiv’s energy corridors associated to the loss of life in early March of Denys Kirieiev, a former financial institution govt, a number of sources stated. He was a member of the Ukrainian delegation that took half in short-lived talks with Russian negotiators on the Ukraine-Belarus border, beginning on February 28. {A photograph} confirmed Kirieiev sitting alongside Ukrainian officers on the negotiating desk.
An advisor to the Zelenskiy administration stated, in an internet interview, that officers from the SBU shot Kirieiev whereas making an attempt to arrest him as a Russian spy.
However Ukraine’s Army Intelligence Company stated Kirieiev was its worker and intelligence officer, and that he died a hero whereas conducting an unspecified particular project defending Ukraine. A supply near the Ukrainian navy instructed Reuters that Kirieiev was certainly a spy working for Ukraine. He had entry to the very best ranges of the Russian management, this supply stated, and was feeding again worthwhile info on invasion plans and different issues to his handlers in Kyiv.
Amid the chaos early within the conflict, Bakanov, then the pinnacle of the SBU, left Kyiv for no less than three days after the Russian invasion, in response to three individuals in Ukrainian regulation enforcement. Two of those individuals stated some SBU employees recounted they had been unable to succeed in Bakanov for a number of days after Russia invaded. In suspending Bakanov on July 17, Zelenskiy cited an article in Ukraine’s Armed Forces statute, underneath which servicemen may be relieved of their duties for improper conduct resulting in casualties or a risk of casualties.
Bakanov and the SBU didn’t reply to Reuters’ questions.
Zelenskiy, in his speech, careworn the toll Russian infiltration was taking up his embattled nation by talking of the quite a few officers who’ve been accused of betraying Ukraine.
“Such an array of crimes in opposition to the foundations of the nationwide safety of the state … poses very severe inquiries to the related leaders,” Zelenskiy stated.
“Every of those questions will obtain a correct reply.”
In lower than two hours, and with out a struggle, the 169 members of the Ukrainian Nationwide Guard laid down their weapons. Russia had taken Chornobyl, a repository for tonnes of nuclear materials and a key staging publish on the strategy to Kyiv.
The autumn of Chornobyl, web site of the world’s worst nuclear catastrophe, stands out as an anomaly within the five-month outdated conflict: a profitable blitzkrieg operation in a battle marked elsewhere by a brutal and halting advance by Russian troops and grinding resistance by Ukraine.
Now a Reuters investigation has discovered that Russia’s success at Chornobyl was no accident, however a part of a long-standing Kremlin operation to infiltrate the Ukrainian state with secret brokers.
5 individuals with information of the Kremlin’s preparations stated conflict planners round President Vladimir Putin believed that, aided by these brokers, Russia would require solely a small navy power and some days to power Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy’s administration to give up, flee or capitulate.
By interviews with dozens of officers in Russia and Ukraine and a assessment of Ukrainian courtroom paperwork and statements to investigators, associated to a probe into the conduct of people that labored at Chornobyl, Reuters has established that this infiltration reached far deeper than has been publicly acknowledged. The officers interviewed embody individuals inside Russia who had been briefed on Moscow’s invasion planning and Ukrainian investigators tasked with monitoring down spies.
“Aside from the exterior enemy, we sadly have an inside enemy, and this enemy is not any much less harmful,” the secretary of Ukraine’s Nationwide Safety and Defence Council, Oleksiy Danilov, stated in an interview.
On the time of the invasion, Danilov stated, Russia had brokers within the Ukrainian defence, safety and regulation enforcement sectors. He declined to provide names however stated such traitors wanted to be “neutralised” in any respect prices.
Ukraine’s State Bureau of Investigation is conducting a probe into whether or not the Nationwide Guard acted unlawfully by surrendering its weapons to an enemy, an area official instructed Reuters. The State Bureau of Investigation did not remark. The Nationwide Guard defended the actions of its unit on the plant, pointing to the dangers of battle at a nuclear web site.
Courtroom paperwork and testimony, reported right here for the primary time, reveal the function performed by Chornobyl’s head of safety, Valentin Viter, who’s in detention and is being investigated for absenting himself from his publish. An extract from the state register of pre-trial investigations, seen by Reuters, exhibits Viter can be suspected of treason, an allegation his lawyer says is unfounded. In a press release to investigators, Viter stated that on the day of the invasion he spoke by telephone with the Nationwide Guard unit commander. Viter suggested the commander to not endanger his unit, telling him: “Spare your individuals.”
One supply with direct information of the Kremlin’s invasion plans instructed Reuters that Russian brokers had been deployed to Chornobyl final 12 months to bribe officers and put together the bottom for a cold takeover. Reuters could not independently confirm the main points of this assertion. Nevertheless, Ukraine’s State Bureau of Investigation has stated it’s investigating a former high intelligence official, Andriy Naumov, on suspicion of treason for passing Chornobyl safety secrets and techniques to a international state. A lawyer for Naumov declined to remark.
At a nationwide degree, sources with information of the Kremlin’s plans stated Moscow was relying on activating sleeper brokers contained in the Ukrainian safety equipment. The sources confirmed Western intelligence reviews that the Kremlin was lining up Oleg Tsaryov, a hotelier, to guide a puppet authorities in Kyiv. And a former Ukrainian prosecutor basic disclosed to Reuters in June that Ukrainian politician Viktor Medvedchuk, a buddy of Putin, had an encrypted telephone issued by Russia so he may talk with the Kremlin.
Tsaryov stated the Reuters account of how Moscow’s operation total unfolded “has little or no to do with actuality.” He didn’t handle his relationship with the Kremlin. A lawyer for Medvedchuk declined to remark. Medvedchuk is in a Ukrainian jail awaiting trial on treason costs that pre-date the Russian invasion.
Although Russia captured Chornobyl, its plan to take energy in Kyiv failed. In lots of instances, the sleeper brokers Moscow had put in didn’t do their job, in response to a number of sources in Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine Safety Council Secretary Danilov stated the brokers and their handlers believed Ukraine was weak, which was “a complete false impression.”
Folks the Kremlin counted on as its proxies in Ukraine overstated their affect within the years main as much as the invasion, stated 4 of the sources with information of the Kremlin’s preparations. The Kremlin relied in its planning on “clowns – they know slightly bit, however they all the time say what the management needs to listen to as a result of in any other case they will not receives a commission,” stated one of many 4, an individual near the Moscow-backed separatist management in japanese Ukraine.
Putin now finds himself in a protracted, full-scale conflict, preventing for each inch of territory at enormous value.
However the Russian intelligence infiltration did achieve a technique: It has sown distrust inside Ukraine and laid naked the shortcomings of Ukraine’s close to 30,000-strong Safety Service of Ukraine, or SBU, which shares an advanced historical past with Russia, and is now tasked with looking down traitors and collaborators.
This inside Ukrainian turmoil burst into partial view on July 17. In a video handle to the nation, President Zelenskiy suspended SBU head Ivan Bakanov, whom he has recognized for years, citing the massive variety of SBU employees suspected of treason. Ukrainian regulation enforcement sources instructed Reuters that some SBU employees recounted in dialog with them that they had been unable to succeed in Bakanov for a number of days after Russia invaded, including to a way of chaos in Kyiv. Bakanov did not reply to Reuters’ requests for remark.
Zelenskiy additionally stated 651 instances of alleged treason and collaboration have been opened in opposition to people concerned in regulation enforcement and within the prosecutor’s workplace. Greater than 60 officers from the SBU and the prosecutor basic’s workplace are working in opposition to Ukraine in Russian-occupied zones, Zelenskiy added.
Requested to touch upon Reuters’ findings, the Ukrainian presidential administration, the SBU and the prosecutor basic’s workplace didn’t reply. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov stated: “All these questions haven’t any relation in any way to us, subsequently there may be nothing for us to touch upon right here.” The Russian intelligence company, the FSB, and the defence ministry didn’t reply to Reuters’ questions.
KGB ties
Moscow’s spy equipment has been intertwined with Chornobyl for many years. After the 1986 catastrophe, when a reactor blew up scattering radioactive clouds throughout Europe, the Soviet KGB stepped in. Greater than 1,000 KGB employees took half within the clean-up, in response to a declassified inside memo to a Ukrainian authorities minister, dated 1991. Then-KGB boss Viktor Chebrikov ordered his officers to recruit brokers among the many plant’s employees and instructed {that a} KGB officer ought to maintain the publish of deputy boss of the plant in command of safety, in response to one other memo – an inside KGB communication from 1986.
Even after Ukraine turned unbiased in 1991, Moscow’s spy chiefs remained highly effective there. The primary head of Ukraine’s home intelligence service was Nikolai Golushko, who began his profession in Soviet Russia. Earlier than his appointment he led the Ukraine arm of the Soviet KGB. Golushko saved many of the Soviet-era officers of their jobs, he wrote in a 2012 memoir.
After 4 months as Ukraine’s spy chief, Golushko moved again to Moscow to rejoin KGB headquarters, and in 1993 turned head of Russia’s newly created Federal Counter-Intelligence Service, precursor to at this time’s FSB.
In Moscow, Golushko obtained a go to from the deputy head of Ukraine’s State Safety Service, Golushko wrote within the memoir. He recalled how Oleg Pugach, the Ukrainian official, requested for Golushko’s assist discovering material to make the uniforms for Ukraine’s intelligence officers. Golushko additionally wrote that Kyiv, wanting its personal assets and experience, signed offers underneath which the SBU agreed to share intelligence info with Moscow. In change, Moscow offered provides, know-how and knowledgeable assist with investigations. Reuters approached Golushko for remark. A colleague from an intelligence veterans’ group instructed Reuters Golushko, now 85, was in unwell well being and couldn’t reply questions. Reuters was unable to succeed in Pugach and could not independently verify Golushko’s account.
Intelligence officers working at Chornobyl formally turned a part of Ukraine’s safety equipment in 1991, however they continued to take orders from Moscow, stated the individual with direct information of the invasion plan. “In impact, these had been FSB workers,” stated the individual. The SBU didn’t reply to questions on Chornobyl or historic ties to Russian intelligence.
The Chornobyl nuclear plant is an unlimited facility. A large metal construction encases Reactor No. 4, floor zero of the 1986 catastrophe. The plant lies simply 10 kilometres on the closest level from the border with Belarus, in a dense and extremely irradiated forest. Russia’s conflict planners thought of management of Chornobyl to be strategically essential as a result of it sat on the shortest route for his or her advance on Kyiv, in response to Western navy analysts.
The supply with direct information of the invasion plan stated that in November 2021 Russia began sending undercover intelligence brokers to Ukraine, tasked with establishing contacts with officers accountable for securing the Chornobyl energy plant. The brokers’ purpose was to make sure there could be no armed resistance as soon as Russian troops rolled in. The supply stated Chornobyl additionally served as a drop-off level for paperwork from SBU headquarters. In return for cost, Ukrainian officers handed Russian spies details about Ukraine’s navy readiness.
Reuters couldn’t independently confirm particulars of the supply’s account, and neither Ukraine’s State Bureau of Investigation nor the SBU responded to the information company’s questions. However a assessment of Ukrainian testimony and courtroom paperwork and an interview with an area official present that Kyiv is conducting no less than three investigations into the conduct of people that labored at Chornobyl. The investigations have recognized no less than two individuals suspected of offering info to Russian brokers or in any other case serving to them seize the plant, in response to these paperwork.
One of many males suspected by Ukrainian prosecutors and investigators of serving to Russian forces is Valentin Viter, a 47-year-old colonel within the SBU. On the time of the Russian invasion, Viter was the deputy general-director of the plant accountable for its bodily safety.
In Might final 12 months, Viter oversaw a routine coaching train that was meant to simulate an assault by armed saboteurs. Armed members of the Nationwide Guard unit that protects Chornobyl took half, and rehearsed repelling the attackers by power. Viter stated the train was a hit, in response to a video interview posted shortly afterwards on the plant’s web site. He additionally stated he hoped Chornobyl’s safety staff would “not want to use the information and expertise we acquired in a real-life state of affairs.”
Viter was seconded from the SBU to work at Chornobyl as safety chief in mid-2019, in response to a press release he gave to investigators. In an extra assertion, he stated that on February 18 this 12 months – six days earlier than the Russian invasion – he went on sick go away with a respiratory downside.
By then, Russia was bolstering its troops in Belarus in preparation for an invasion, U.S. officers stated on the time. Satellite tv for pc pictures shot by U.S. satellite tv for pc imagery firm Maxar on February 15 confirmed a navy pontoon bridge underneath development throughout the Pripyat River in Belarus, north of the ability plant. Ukraine’s police, and the SBU, had been on heightened alert in response to the Russian risk, and the nationwide police chief stated in a press release on the time that safety was bolstered on the Chornobyl plant.
On the morning of the Russian invasion, February 24, Viter stated, in a press release to investigators, that he was at his dwelling in Kyiv. He telephoned the pinnacle of the Chornobyl Nationwide Guard unit, who was at his publish. By then, individuals on the plant knew a column of Russian armoured automobiles was heading their approach.
Viter, in response to his testimony to Ukrainian investigators, instructed the commander, in Russian: “Spare your individuals.” Viter had no official authority over the Nationwide Guard, and Reuters couldn’t decide whether or not the commander was heeding Viter’s phrases when the unit surrendered after discussions with the Russian invaders. A Nationwide Guard assertion recognized the unit commander as Yuriy Pindak.
When the Russian troopers lastly retreated from Chornobyl after a 36-day occupation, they took Pindak and most of his unit away as captives. Ukraine says the guards are being held in Russia or Belarus. Russian officers didn’t touch upon the unit’s whereabouts.
Ukraine’s State Bureau of Investigation is conducting a probe into whether or not the Nationwide Guard broke the regulation by laying down arms, stated Yuriy Fomichev, mayor of the city of Slavutych the place many of the Chornobyl staff dwell. Fomichev stated he was not conscious of anybody having been charged. The State Bureau of Investigation did not reply to Reuters’ questions concerning the matter.
The Nationwide Guard declined to touch upon the actions of particular person commanders and members of the unit tasked with defending Chornobyl. “Combating on the territory of nuclear amenities is prohibited by the Geneva Conference,” it stated, including that this was “one of many causes” why there was no heavy preventing on the web site. It referred questions on any investigation to the Bureau.
Article 56 of a further protocol to the Geneva Conventions states that nuclear energy crops and different harmful installations shouldn’t be attacked.
Viter was arrested in western Ukraine and is now in pre-trial detention there on suspicion of absenting himself from his publish. An extract from the courtroom’s register, seen by Reuters, exhibits that regulation enforcement brokers have initiated a second investigation into Viter for suspected treason by “intentionally helping the navy items of the aggressor nation, the Russian Federation, in finishing up subversive actions in opposition to Ukraine.” They’ve but to uncover proof tying him to Russian particular companies.
Viter has stated in courtroom statements that he fled Kyiv for the protection of his household two days after Chornobyl was seized however tried to remain in touch with colleagues on the plant.
His lawyer, Oleksandr Kovalenko, stated Viter had a official motive for being off work and was unaware that he ought to keep at Chornobyl. The lawyer stated any treason allegation was unfounded and Viter had not been served with a letter of suspicion, a step which often precedes costs. In accordance with the lawyer, Viter stated “Spare your individuals” to remind the Nationwide Guard commander that many individuals trusted him. Viter didn’t focus on give up, Kovalenko stated. He added that investigators had not requested Viter about any change of paperwork at Chornobyl.
Money and emeralds
The extent to which Russia infiltrated Chornobyl has targeted Ukrainian authorities’ consideration on the SBU, the company Viter labored for, sources stated. Particularly, navy prosecutors on Viter’s case are concerned with his connection to a former Ukrainian official known as Andriy Naumov, in response to sources with information of the investigation and a transcript of Viter’s questioning seen by Reuters.
Beforehand an official within the Ukrainian prosecutor’s workplace, by 2018 Naumov had been appointed head of COTIZ, a state enterprise accountable for estate-management of the radioactive exclusion zone round Chornobyl. A serious a part of COTIZ’s function was to advertise “excessive tourism” within the exclusion zone, however the enterprise additionally had a task in holding the location safe, in response to its web site.
After his stint at Chornobyl, Naumov was made the pinnacle of the SBU’s division of inside safety, a division that investigates different officers suspected of prison exercise. Final 12 months, the company stated it thwarted an assassination try on Naumov by different SBU officers. Naumov was later fired as division chief, in response to Ukrainian media outlet Ukrainska Pravda and a regulation enforcement supply.
Naumov vanished shortly earlier than the invasion, an individual in regulation enforcement stated. He ultimately turned up in Serbia in June. A Serbian police assertion issued on June 8 stated police and anti-corruption brokers had arrested a Ukrainian citizen recognized by the initials “A.N.” on the border with North Macedonia. He had been making an attempt to cross into North Macedonia from Serbia. A search of the BMW wherein he was a passenger uncovered $124,924 and 607,990 euros in money, plus two emeralds, the assertion stated. It stated the person and the unnamed driver of the BMW, who was additionally detained, had been suspected of desiring to launder the money and emeralds, which police consider originated from prison actions. Volodymyr Tolkach, Ukraine’s ambassador to Serbia, publicly confirmed the arrested man was Naumov.
The State Bureau of Investigation confirmed an area media report that it’s conducting a pre-trial investigation into Naumov for state treason. It stated it was wanting into whether or not Naumov collected info on the safety set-up at Chornobyl whereas working on the plant and later on the SBU and handed it to a international state. The assertion didn’t say what grounds it had for suspecting he handed on secrets and techniques or if it had particular proof linking him to Russia.
On March 31, President Zelenskiy issued a decree stripping Naumov of his brigadier-general rank. The identical day, the Ukrainian president introduced in an emotional handle that Naumov and one other SBU basic had been “traitors” who violated their oath of allegiance to Ukraine. Zelenskiy didn’t make reference to Chornobyl.
Naumov stays in detention in Serbia and couldn’t be reached for remark. His lawyer in Serbia, Viktor Gostiljac, declined to remark. The SBU didn’t reply to questions on Naumov.
Decapitation
For Russia’s conflict planners, seizing Chornobyl was only a stepping stone to the primary goal: taking management of the Ukrainian nationwide authorities in Kyiv. There, too, the Kremlin anticipated that undercover brokers in positions of energy would play a vital half, in response to 4 sources with information of the plan.
Yuriy Lutsenko, who served as Ukraine’s prosecutor basic from 2016 till 2019, revealed to Reuters that on the time he left the function “lots of” of Defence Ministry workers had been underneath surveillance, authorised by his workplace, as a result of they had been suspected of ties to the Russian state. Lutsenko stated he believed there have been related numbers of suspected spies in different ministries.
Russia’s conflict planners had been additionally relying on different allies to assist in the takeover, 5 sources stated.
Some of the seen loyalists was Viktor Medvedchuk, a frontrunner of Ukraine’s Opposition Platform – For Life social gathering. Putin is god-father to one among Medvedchuk’s kids. Since 2014, Medvedchuk has been a vocal opponent of the favored protests that known as for nearer ties to the European Union.
Medvedchuk was charged with state treason on Might 11, 2021. Investigators from the SBU alleged on the time that Medvedchuk handed secret particulars about Ukrainian navy items to Russian officers, and supposed to recruit Ukrainian brokers and covertly affect Ukrainian politics. The day earlier than the invasion, he left his dwelling in Kyiv and was planning on leaving the nation, in violation of the phrases of his bail, in response to the SBU.
Medvedchuk was detained on April 12, Zelenskiy introduced that day. Zelenskiy instantly posted footage of him handcuffed, in Ukrainian navy fatigues and looking out bedraggled. Medvedchuk has since been in detention.
Medvedchuk has denied the treason costs, saying they had been falsified and a part of a political plot in opposition to him. Kremlin spokesman Peskov instructed reporters on April 13 Medvedchuk had no back-channel communication with the Russian management.
Lutsenko, the previous Ukraine prosecutor basic, instructed Reuters that earlier than the Russian invasion, Medvedchuk used an encrypted phone that was issued to him by the Kremlin, gear reserved just for essentially the most senior Russian officers and pro-Russian separatist leaders. Lutsenko stated Ukrainian investigators had managed to hack the encrypted telephone system, with out disclosing what they discovered.
Medvedchuk’s lawyer, Tetyana Zhukovska, declined to remark till a courtroom has handed down a choice within the case. The Ukrainian prosecutor’s workplace didn’t remark.
One other key determine, in response to three sources aware of the Russian plans, was Oleg Tsaryov, a square-jawed 52-year-old former member of Ukraine’s parliament. He was picked by Kremlin invasion planners to guide the brand new interim authorities they deliberate to put in, these sources stated. Their feedback are the primary affirmation from inside Russia of U.S. intelligence assessments, reported by the Monetary Instances earlier this 12 months, that Moscow was contemplating placing Tsaryov in a management function in a puppet authorities in Kyiv.
Tsaryov has been underneath Ukrainian and U.S. sanctions since 2014, when, after a bid to win election as Ukrainian president collapsed, he headed up a physique known as “Novorossiya,” or New Russia. The group pushed the thought of turning southeastern Ukraine right into a separate pro-Russian statelet. By the beginning of this 12 months, he was in Russian-annexed Crimea, the place he owns two lodges.
Within the early hours of February 24, in the beginning of the invasion, Tsaryov instructed his greater than 200,000 Telegram followers he had crossed into Kyiv-controlled territory. “I am in Ukraine. Kyiv can be free from fascists.”
However Zelenskiy didn’t capitulate. Any expectations in Moscow that he would flee Kyiv or negotiate a deal that will cede to Russia’s calls for quickly evaporated. Within the weeks that adopted, Ukrainian forces halted Russian troops’ advance on Kyiv.
Tsaryov by no means made it to the capital. On June 10, he posted an commercial to his Telegram followers for his seaside resort in Crimea, the place a one-night keep prices 1,500 roubles ($28) per individual per evening. Tsaryov is now spending his time in Crimea with visits to Moscow, in response to his social media posts.
Paranoia and distrust
Russia’s marketing campaign of infiltration did, nevertheless, stir suspicion and distrust at some ranges of the Ukrainian state, which hampered its capacity to manipulate, particularly within the first few days after the invasion.
One stark incident that fuelled the tensions in Kyiv’s energy corridors associated to the loss of life in early March of Denys Kirieiev, a former financial institution govt, a number of sources stated. He was a member of the Ukrainian delegation that took half in short-lived talks with Russian negotiators on the Ukraine-Belarus border, beginning on February 28. {A photograph} confirmed Kirieiev sitting alongside Ukrainian officers on the negotiating desk.
An advisor to the Zelenskiy administration stated, in an internet interview, that officers from the SBU shot Kirieiev whereas making an attempt to arrest him as a Russian spy.
However Ukraine’s Army Intelligence Company stated Kirieiev was its worker and intelligence officer, and that he died a hero whereas conducting an unspecified particular project defending Ukraine. A supply near the Ukrainian navy instructed Reuters that Kirieiev was certainly a spy working for Ukraine. He had entry to the very best ranges of the Russian management, this supply stated, and was feeding again worthwhile info on invasion plans and different issues to his handlers in Kyiv.
Amid the chaos early within the conflict, Bakanov, then the pinnacle of the SBU, left Kyiv for no less than three days after the Russian invasion, in response to three individuals in Ukrainian regulation enforcement. Two of those individuals stated some SBU employees recounted they had been unable to succeed in Bakanov for a number of days after Russia invaded. In suspending Bakanov on July 17, Zelenskiy cited an article in Ukraine’s Armed Forces statute, underneath which servicemen may be relieved of their duties for improper conduct resulting in casualties or a risk of casualties.
Bakanov and the SBU didn’t reply to Reuters’ questions.
Zelenskiy, in his speech, careworn the toll Russian infiltration was taking up his embattled nation by talking of the quite a few officers who’ve been accused of betraying Ukraine.
“Such an array of crimes in opposition to the foundations of the nationwide safety of the state … poses very severe inquiries to the related leaders,” Zelenskiy stated.
“Every of those questions will obtain a correct reply.”